Return to insights

Behavioural Finance and the Curse of Karna

22 January 2018

By Rohan Advant, CFA
  • Behavioral Finance
  • Investment Insights

In the epic, the Mahabharata, on the final day of the lessons from his guru, Parashurama, Karna bravely bore a scorpion’s sting while Parashurama was resting his head upon his lap. As the blood from Karna’s thigh trickled down and disturbed the sleeping Parashurama, he realized that only a Kshatriya (a warrior) could bear such pain without a murmur and that he had been tricked by Karna into believing he was a Brahmana (of the priestly class). Karna explained that he was actually a Suta (a mixture of Brahmana and Kshatriya) in an attempt to placate his irate teacher. Furious at being deceived, Parashurama cursed Karna that he would be unable to use weapons, especially the Brahmastra, when he needed them the most. This curse came into effect when Karna was unable to remember the incantation to invoke the Brahmastra while fighting against Arjun on the battlefield.

I often wonder if investors suffer from a similar curse that Parashurama gave to Karna. One can read all the books on behavioural finance and listen to advice from the legends of investing but what really matters is how one applies this knowledge at the most crucial times. While many have the intelligence to understand behavioural biases, few have the wisdom to apply them in real-life scenarios.

Here are some scenarios where I have observed that it is very difficult to stay unbiased and think rationally

1. When a high quality Company goes through a company specific crisis.
In my investing career, I have seen many high quality companies going through a crisis. Be it the Maruti Manesar crisis, the MCX NSEL crisis, the Nestle Maggi crisis, the Divi’s USFDA crisis, etc.

2. When a high quality Company faces sector-specific headwinds.
There are also many themes like Pharmaceutical, Information Technology, micro-finance which I have seen go through periods of extremely positive and extremely negative investor sentiment.

3. A high quality Company with a large addressable market going through a period of overvaluation.
There are times when a good Company with a large addressable market trades at absurd valuations. For example, Infosys at its 2000 peak had a market cap of INR 92,000 crores and its FY2000 PAT was INR 300 crores.

4. The market turns agnostic to quality and determines cheapness just based on P/E ratios
There are times in the bull market when Stock A is considered cheaper than Stock B just because it trades at a lower P/E and no attention is paid towards comparing the balance sheet, cash-flow generations or return ratios of the two companies.

While the lessons from behavioural finance are generally useful, it is in situations like the ones mentioned above that they become absolutely vital. And, it is precisely at these moments that they are most difficult to follow. Why is that so?

In the excellent book “Halo effect” by Phil Rosenzweig, the author states “there will always be a temptation to tell a neat story that makes everything sensible and logical and that suggests why the deserving succeeded while the wicked or the arrogant failed”. And this tendency of humans to justify to themselves the stock price performance (positive or negative) is what leads to their inability to think rationally during such times. Neat stories are published in broker reports, newspapers, and business magazines glorifying the companies whose stock price has shot up in the last few months and demonising those companies whose stock price has not performed. Most people think of stock price as a result of these stories but my observation is that these stories are actually a result of the stock price. Like Warren Buffett commented in the late 1960s “We live in an investment world, populated not by those who must be logically persuaded to believe, but by the hopeful, credulous and greedy, grasping for an excuse to believe.”

There is also an angle of human biology to such a behaviour. In the excellent book “The Hour between Dog and Wolf” by Dr. John Coates, the author explains how human biology contributes to the alternating cycles of irrational exuberance and pessimism. Given below is an excerpt from the book:-

“Most models in economics and finance assume that risk preferences are a stable trait, much like your height. But this assumption, as our studies suggest, is misleading. Humans are designed with shifting risk preferences. They are an integral part of our response to stress, or challenge.

When opportunities abound (bull markets), a potent cocktail of dopamine — a neurotransmitter operating along the pleasure pathways of the brain — and testosterone encourages us to expand our risk taking, a physical transformation I refer to as “the hour between dog and wolf.”

Under conditions of extreme volatility, such as a crisis, traders, investors and indeed whole companies can freeze up in risk aversion (through the release of the stress hormone – cortisol), and this helps push a bear market into a crash. Unfortunately, this risk aversion occurs at just the wrong time, for these crises are precisely when markets offer the most attractive opportunities, and when the economy most needs people to take risks”.

Thus, one needs to understand that in such extreme times, the market participants are actually under the influence of a naturally produced narcotic that transforms them into different people. And thus, while it’s easy to explain things in hindsight after the dust has settled, it’s extremely difficult to stay brutally rational and unbiased in a live volatile situation.

Just as Karna could not remember the mantras he needed to invoke his weapon, perhaps so too do investors forget to invoke the teachings of their financial gurus and remain steadfast to their original investment plans when the need arises the most. Fortunately for them, lifting ‘the curse of Karna’ remains in their power.

Download Article PDF

Recent Articles

Assessing the effectiveness of mutual fund categories in Indian portfolios

Amogh Korde, Project Lead – Behavioural and Fund Analytics at Multi-Act, delves into the ever-evolving investment landscape … Continued

Read more

PSU Stocks – Still Risk-Reward Favourable?

When I consider PSU stocks, I’m reminded of the famous song of Bob Dylan, “The Times They … Continued

Read more

Key red flags in India’s economic horizon

The Indian economy is on a promising trajectory, with expectations of robust GDP growth surpassing 6.5% in … Continued

Read more

Stay up to date with Multi-Act

Receive monthly updates by signing up to our newsletter.

Current complaints

Data for the month ending - Mar, 2024

Complaints status
Sr. No. Received from Pending at the end of last month Received Resolved* Total Pending # Pending complaints > 3 months Average Resolution time^ (in days)
1 Directly from Investors 0 0 0 0 0 0
2 SEBI (SCORES) 0 0 0 0 0 0
3 Other Sources
(if any)
0 0 0 0 0 0
Grand Total 0 0 0 0 0 0
^ Average Resolution time is the sum total of time taken to resolve each complaint in days, in the current month divided by total number of complaints resolved in the current month.

Trend of Monthly Disposal of Complaints

Sr. No. Month Carried forward from previous month Received Resolved* Pending#
1 April 2023 0 0 0 0
2 May 2023 0 0 0 0
3 June 2023 0 0 0 0
4 July 2023 0 0 0 0
5 August 2023 0 0 0 0
6 September 2023 0 0 0 0
7 October 2023 0 0 0 0
8 November 2023 0 0 0 0
9 December 2023 0 0 0 0
10 January 2024 0 0 0 0
10 February 2024 0 0 0 0
11 March 2024 0 0 0 0
Grand Total
*Inclusive of complaints of previous months resolved in the current month. #Inclusive of complaints pending as on the last day of the month.

Trend of Annual Disposal of Complaints

Sr. No. Year Carried forward from previous year Received Resolved* Pending#
1 2019-20 0 0 0 0
2 2020-21 0 0 0 0
3 2021-22 0 0 0 0
4 2022-23 0 0 0 0
Grand Total 0 0 0 0
*Inclusive of complaints of previous months resolved in the current month. #Inclusive of complaints pending as on the last day of the year.